Method and apparatus for determining harq timing in communication systems

ABSTRACT

Methods and apparatuses for determining HARQ timing in a communication system supporting Carrier Aggregation (CA) are provided. A method for receiving, at a BS, a HARQ feedback from a UE in a communication system supporting CA of a Pcell and at least one Scell is provided. The Pcell and Scell support either FDD or TDD. The method comprises: transmitting a downlink physical channel through one of the Pcell and Scell; receiving the HARQ feedback corresponding to the downlink physical channel of the Pcell at a first timing predetermined for the Pcell; and receiving the HARQ feedback corresponding to the downlink physical channel of the Scell at a second timing. The second timing is determined according to one or more of duplex modes of the Pcell and the Scell, a scheduling mode of the Scell, and predefined rules.

TECHNICAL FIELD

Embodiments of the present invention generally relate to a wirelesscommunication system, and more particularly to methods, apparatuses, abase station, a user equipment and a computer program for determiningHybrid Automatic Repeat Request (HARQ) timing in a communication systemsupporting Carrier Aggregation (CA).

BACKGROUND

This section introduces aspects that may facilitate a betterunderstanding of the invention(s). Accordingly, the statements of thissection are to be read in this light and are not to be understood asadmissions about what is in the prior art or what is not in the priorart.

Long Term Evolution (LTE) and LTE-Advanced (LTE-A) standards and/orprotocols defined by the Third Generation Partnership Project (3GPP,3GPP2) are one of the next generation cellular communication standards.According to the multiplexing method, LTE and LTE-A systems include twomodes, Frequency Division Duplex (FDD) and Time Division Duplex (TDD).Service providers are expected to implement both types of systemsdepending on the circumstances of the deployment scenario. Theadvantages to deploying a TDD system include providing flexible resourceutilization (e.g., based on traffic characteristics) through differentuplink-downlink (UL-DL) configurations.

To meet LTE-A requirements, support of wider transmission bandwidths isrequired than the 20 MHz bandwidth specified in 3GPP Release 8/9. Thepreferred solution to this is Carrier Aggregation (CA). In CA, two ormore Component Carriers (CCs) are aggregated in order to support widertransmission bandwidths up to 100 MHz. A user equipment (UE) maysimultaneously receive or transmit on one or multiple CCs depending onits capabilities. Combined with inter-band CA, more flexibility can beachieved using carrier aggregation of FDD band and TDD band.

In LTE Release 10, carrier aggregation of FDD and carrier aggregation ofTDD with same UL-DL configuration are supported to get higher data rateand higher spectral efficiency. In LTE Release 11, carrier aggregationof TDD with different UL-DL configurations on different bands is alsosupported to further improve the data rate and spectral efficiency. In3GPP TSG RAN meeting #58, RP-122022, “Further LTE Carrier AggregationEnhancements”, carrier aggregation of FDD and TDD is proposed as a workitem. In CA of FDD and TDD, either TDD or FDD can be configured asprimary cell (Pcell).

Pcell is the cell operating on the primary frequency, in which the UEeither performs the initial connection establishment procedure orinitiates the connection re-establishment procedure, or the cellindicated as the primary cell in the handover procedure. Secondary cell(Scell) is a cell operating on a secondary frequency, which may beconfigured once an RRC connection is established and which may be usedto provide additional radio resources. For a UE in RRC_CONNECTEDconfigured with CA, the term “serving cells” is used to denote the setof one or more cells comprising of the primary cell and all secondarycells.

In order to prepare against a decoding failure that occurs at initialtransmission, LTE/LTE-A adopts Hybrid Automatic Repeat Request (HARQ)for retransmission of the decoding-failed data on the physical layer.

HARQ is a technique in which, when decoding fails, the receiver sendsthe transmitter a Negative ACKnowledgement (NACK) such that thetransmitter retransmits the decoding-failed data. If the data is decodedsuccessfully, the receiver sends the transmitter an ACKnowledgement(ACK) such that the transmitter sends new data.

Normally, the HARQ feedback corresponding to physical downlink channel,for example, Physical Downlink Shared CHannel (PDSCH) is transmitted onphysical uplink channel, such as Physical Uplink Control Channel (PUCCH)or Physical Uplink Shared Channel (PUSCH), according to predefinedtiming, and the HARQ feedback corresponding to physical uplink channel,for example, Physical Uplink Shared CHannel (PUSCH) is transmitted onphysical downlink channel, such as Physical Hybrid ARQ Indicator CHannel(PHICH), according to predefined timing.

In European patent application EP2530863A2, a method for definingphysical channel transmit/receiving timings and resource allocation isprovided for use in a TDD system supporting CA.

However, in the prior art, there is no solution for defining HARQfeedback timing for a communication system supporting CA of FDD and TDD.

SUMMARY

To better address one or more of the above concerns, in a first aspectof the invention, a method for receiving, at a base station, a HybridAutomatic Repeat Request (HARQ) feedback from a user equipment in acommunication system supporting Carrier Aggregation (CA) of a primarycell and at least one secondary cell is provided. The primary cell andsecondary cell support either Frequency Divisional Duplex (FDD) or TimeDivisional Duplex (TDD). The method comprises: transmitting a downlinkphysical channel through one of the primary and secondary cells;receiving the HARQ feedback corresponding to the downlink physicalchannel of the primary cell at a first timing predetermined for theprimary cell; and receiving the HARQ feedback corresponding to thedownlink physical channel of the secondary cell at a second timing. Thesecond timing is determined according to one or more of duplex modes ofthe primary cell and the secondary cell, a scheduling mode of thesecondary cell, and predefined rules.

In some embodiments, the duplex mode is selected from TDD and FDD, thescheduling mode is selected from self scheduling and cross carrierscheduling, and the predefined rules comprise the HARQ feedback can onlybe transmitted on a component carrier of the primary cell.

In some embodiments, the second timing is identical with the firsttiming, for both self scheduling and cross carrier scheduling of thesecondary cell, when the primary cell is configured as FDD.

In some embodiments, the second timing is identical with the firsttiming, for cross carrier scheduling of the secondary cell, when theprimary cell is configured as TDD.

In some embodiments, the second timing is determined according to anyone of the following, for self scheduling of the secondary cell, whenthe primary cell is configured as TDD and said secondary cell isconfigured as FDD: being identical with the first timing; beingidentical with a third timing for a TDD configuration which has moreavailable downlink subframes than the TDD configuration of the primarycell; and a fourth timing specific to said secondary cell.

In further embodiments, the fourth timing is determined as below: for afirst downlink subframe which is also downlink subframe in the primarycell, the timing of the first downlink subframe is identical with thefirst timing; and for a second downlink subframe which is uplinksubframe in the primary cell, the timing of the second downlink subframeis identical with a maximum of a timing of a downlink subframe of theprimary cell which is closest to the second downlink subframe and aprocessing delay. Optionally, the fourth timing is further adjustedaccording to the number of uplink subframes of the primary cell tobalance the HARQ feedback among the uplink subframes of the primarycell, meanwhile minimizing HARQ feedback delay.

In a second aspect of the invention, a method for transmitting, at auser equipment, a Hybrid Automatic Repeat Request (HARQ) feedback to abase station in a communication system supporting Carrier Aggregation(CA) of a primary cell and at least one secondary cell is provided. Theprimary cell and secondary cell support either Frequency DivisionalDuplex (FDD) or Time Divisional Duplex (TDD). The method comprises:receiving a downlink physical channel through one of the primary andsecondary cells; transmitting the HARQ feedback corresponding to thedownlink physical channel of the primary cell at a first timingpredetermined for the primary cell; and transmitting the HARQ feedbackcorresponding to the downlink physical channel of the secondary cell ata second timing. The second timing is determined according to one ormore of duplex modes of the primary cell and the secondary cell, ascheduling mode of the secondary cell, and predefined rules.

In a third aspect of the invention, a method for transmitting, at a basestation, a Hybrid Automatic Repeat Request (HARQ) feedback to a userequipment in a communication system supporting Carrier Aggregation (CA)of a primary cell and at least one secondary cell is provided. Theprimary cell and secondary cell support either Frequency DivisionalDuplex (FDD) or Time Divisional Duplex (TDD). The method comprises:receiving an uplink physical channel through one of the primary andsecondary cells; transmitting the HARQ feedback corresponding to theuplink physical channel of the primary cell at a first timingpredetermined for the primary cell; and transmitting the HARQ feedbackcorresponding to the uplink physical channel of the secondary cell at asecond timing. The second timing is determined according to one or moreof duplex modes of the primary cell and the secondary cell, a schedulingmode of the secondary cell, and predefined rules.

In some embodiments, the duplex mode is selected from TDD and FDD, thescheduling mode is selected from self scheduling and cross carrierscheduling, and the predefined rules comprise the HARQ feedback can onlybe transmitted on a component carrier which carriers an uplink grant.

In some embodiments, for self scheduling, the second timing is identicalwith a timing predetermined for the secondary cell.

In some embodiments, for cross carrier scheduling, the second timing isfurther determined according to the duplex modes of a scheduling celland a scheduled cell.

In further embodiments, the second timing is identical with a timingpredetermined for the secondary cell when the secondary cell is ascheduling cell.

In further embodiments, the second timing is identical with a timingpredetermined for the secondary cell when the secondary cell isconfigured as TDD and scheduled by a FDD component carrier cell.

Further, the second timing is determined according to any one of thefollowing, when the secondary cell is configured as FDD and scheduled bya TDD component carrier cell; being identical with the first timing; andbeing identical with a third timing for a TDD configuration which canuse uplink subframes of the secondary cell as much as possible.

In a fourth aspect of the invention, a method for receiving, at a userequipment, a Hybrid Automatic Repeat Request (HARQ) feedback from a basestation in a communication system supporting Carrier Aggregation (CA) ofa primary cell and at least one secondary cell is provided. The primarycell and secondary cell support either Frequency Divisional Duplex (FDD)or Time Divisional Duplex (TDD). The method comprises: transmitting anuplink physical channel through one of the primary and secondary cells;receiving the HARQ feedback corresponding to the uplink physical channelof the primary cell at a first timing predetermined for the primarycell; and receiving the HARQ feedback corresponding to the uplinkphysical channel of the secondary cell at a second timing. The secondtiming is determined according to one or more of duplex modes of theprimary cell and the secondary cell, a scheduling mode of the secondarycell, and predefined rules.

In a fifth aspect of the invention, an apparatus is provided toimplement various embodiments of the method of the first aspect of theinvention. The apparatus comprises a transmitter configured to transmita downlink physical channel through one of the primary and secondarycells. The apparatus further comprises a receiver configured to receivethe HARQ feedback corresponding to the downlink physical channel of theprimary cell at a first timing predetermined for the primary cell; andto receive the HARQ feedback corresponding to the downlink physicalchannel of the secondary cell at a second timing. The second timing isdetermined according to one or more of duplex modes of the primary celland the secondary cell, a scheduling mode of the secondary cell, andpredefined rules.

In a sixth aspect of the invention, an apparatus is provided toimplement various embodiments of the method of the second aspect of theinvention. The apparatus comprises a receiver configured to receive adownlink physical channel through one of the primary and secondarycells. The apparatus further comprise a transmitter configured totransmit the HARQ feedback corresponding to the downlink physicalchannel of the primary cell at a first timing predetermined for theprimary cell; and to transmit the HARQ feedback corresponding to thedownlink physical channel of the secondary cell at a second timing. Thesecond timing is determined according to one or more of duplex modes ofthe primary cell and the secondary cell, a scheduling mode of thesecondary cell, and predefined rules.

In a seventh aspect of the invention, an apparatus is provided toimplement various embodiments of the method of the third aspect of theinvention. The apparatus comprises a receiver configured to receive anuplink physical channel through one of the primary and secondary cells.The apparatus further comprises a transmitter configured to transmit theHARQ feedback corresponding to the uplink physical channel of theprimary cell at a first timing predetermined for the primary cell; andto transmit the HARQ feedback corresponding to the uplink physicalchannel of the secondary cell at a second timing. The second timing isdetermined according to one or more of duplex modes of the primary celland the secondary cell, a scheduling mode of the secondary cell, andpredefined rules.

In an eighth aspect of the invention, an apparatus is provided toimplement various embodiments of the method of the fourth aspect of theinvention. The apparatus comprises a transmitter configured to transmitan uplink physical channel through one of the primary and secondarycells. The apparatus further comprises a receiver configured to receivethe HARQ feedback corresponding to the uplink physical channel of theprimary cell at a first timing predetermined for the primary cell; andto receive the HARQ feedback corresponding to the uplink physicalchannel of the secondary cell at a second timing. The second timing isdetermined according to one or more of duplex modes of the primary celland the secondary cell, a scheduling mode of the secondary cell, andpredefined rules.

In a ninth aspect of the invention, an apparatus is provided, whichcomprises at least one processor and at least one memory includingcomputer program code. The memory and the computer program code areconfigured to cause the apparatus to perform embodiments of the methodof the first, the second, the third or the fourth aspect of theinvention.

In a tenth aspect of the invention, a computer program product isprovided, which, comprises at least one computer readable storage mediumhaving a computer readable program code portion stored thereon. Thecomputer readable program code portion comprises program codeinstructions for perform embodiments of the method of the first, thesecond, the third or the fourth aspect of the invention.

With particular embodiments of the techniques described in thisspecification, the HARQ feedback timing is defined for communicationsystems supporting CA of FDD and TDD. In some embodiment, high peak ratecan be maintained, mean whiling minimizing the feedback delay.

Other features and advantages of the embodiments of the presentinvention will also be understood from the following description ofspecific embodiments when read in conjunction with the accompanyingdrawings, which illustrate, by way of example, the principles ofembodiments of the present invention.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

The above and other aspects, features, and benefits of variousembodiments of the invention will become more fully apparent, by way ofexample, from the following detailed description and the accompanyingdrawings, in which:

FIG. 1 illustrates the FDD frame structure and the TDD frame structuredefined in LTE system;

FIG. 2 illustrates one exemplary set of uplink/downlink subframeallocations in TDD system;

FIG. 3 illustrates PDSCH HARQ timing for TDD defined in LTEspecification;

FIG. 4 illustrates PUSCH HARQ timing for TDD defined in LTEspecification;

FIG. 5 illustrates PUSCH scheduling timing for TDD defined in LTEspecification;

FIGS. 6a-6b illustrate the scenarios of CA of FDD and TDD;

FIG. 7 illustrates a timing relationship among physical channels for usein a case where the Pcell is configured as FDD according to an exemplaryembodiment of the present invention;

FIG. 8 illustrate a timing relationship among physical channels for usein a case where the Pcell is configured as TDD and the Scell is crosscarrier scheduled, according to an exemplary embodiment of the presentinvention;

FIG. 9 illustrate a first example timing relationship among physicalchannels for use in a case where the Pcell is configured as TDD and theScell (FDD-CC) is self scheduled, according to an exemplary embodimentof the present invention;

FIG. 10 illustrate a second example timing relationship among physicalchannels for use in a case where the Pcell is configured as TDD and theScell (FDD-CC) is self scheduled, according to an exemplary embodimentof the present invention;

FIG. 11 shows a table for the number of available downlink subframesaccording to the second solution;

FIG. 12 depicts an exemplary design process for a Scell (FDD) in a casewhere the Pcell is configured as TDD and the Scell (FDD) is selfscheduled according to a third solution of embodiments of the presentinvention;

FIG. 13 depicts another exemplary design process for a Scell (FDD) in acase where the Pcell is configured as TDD and the Scell (FDD) is selfscheduled according to the third solution of embodiments of the presentinvention;

FIG. 14 illustrates the PDSCH HARQ timing for the Scell (FDD) in a casewhere the Pcell is configured as TDD and the Scell (FDD) is selfscheduled according to the third solution of the present invention:

FIG. 15 illustrates a timing relationship among physical channels foruse in a case where the serving cells are self scheduled, according toan exemplary embodiment of the present invention;

FIG. 16 shows a table for the number of available uplink subframesaccording to Solution B of embodiments of the present invention; and

FIG. 17 illustrates a simplified block diagram of an entity that issuitable for use in practicing the exemplary embodiments of the presentinvention.

Like reference numbers and designations in the various drawings indicatelike elements.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF EMBODIMENTS

Hereinafter, the principle and spirit of the present invention will bedescribed with reference to the illustrative embodiments. It should beunderstood, all these embodiments are given merely for the skilled inthe art to better understand and further practice the present invention,but not for limiting the scope of the present invention. For example,features illustrated or described as part of one embodiment may be usedwith another embodiment to yield still a further embodiment. In theinterest of clarity, not all features of an actual implementation aredescribed in this specification. It will of course be appreciated thatin the development of any such actual embodiment, numerousimplementation-specific decisions should be made to achieve thedevelopers' specific goals, such as compliance with system-related andbusiness-related constraints, which will vary from one implementation toanother. Moreover, it will be appreciated that such a development effortmight be complex and time-consuming, but would nevertheless be a routineundertaking for those of ordinary skill in the art having the benefit ofthis disclosure.

The disclosed subject matter will now be described with reference to theattached figures. Various structures, systems and devices areschematically depicted in the drawings for purposes of explanation onlyand so as to not obscure the description with details that are wellknown to those skilled in the art. Nevertheless, the attached drawingsare included to describe and explain illustrative examples of thedisclosed subject matter. The words and phrases used herein should beunderstood and interpreted to have a meaning consistent with theunderstanding of those words and phrases by those skilled in therelevant art. No special definition of a term or phrase, i.e., adefinition that is different from the ordinary and customary meaning asunderstood by those skilled in the art, is intended to be implied byconsistent usage of the term or phrase herein. To the extent that a termor phrase is intended to have a special meaning, i.e., a meaning otherthan that understood by skilled artisans, such a special definition willbe expressly set forth in the specification in a definitional mannerthat directly and unequivocally provides the special definition for theterm or phrase.

In the following description, a base station (BS) is an entity forallocating resources to a terminal and can be any of an enhanced Node B(eNB), a Node B, a BS, a radio access unit, a base station controller,and a node on a network. The terminal can be a user equipment (UE), amobile station (MS), a cellular phone, a smartphone, a computer, or amultimedia system equipped with communication function.

FIG. 1 shows the FDD frame structure and the TDD frame structure definedin LTE system. As shown in FIG. 1, one radio frame has an overall lengthof 10 ms.

In FDD frame structure, the frame is divided into a total of 10subframes, each having a length of 1 ms. The uplink (UL) subframes andthe downlink (DL) subframes are transmitted on different frequenciesf_(UL) and f_(DL).

In TDD frame structure, the 10 ms frame comprises two half frames, each5 ms long. Each half frame is further split into five subframes, each 1ms long. The subframes may be divided into UL transmission subframe, DLtransmission subframe, and special subframe. The special subframesconsist of three fields: Downlink Pilot Time Slot (DwPTS), Guard Period(GP), and Uplink Pilot Time Slot (UpPTS).

FIG. 2 illustrates one exemplary set of uplink/downlink subframeallocations in TDD system. As shown in FIG. 2, a total of sevenup/downlink configurations have been set, and these use either 5 ms or10 ms switch-point periodicities. In these configurations, differentratios of downlink-to-uplink resources are available for different loadconditions. In the subframes shown in FIG. 2, D is a subframe fordownlink transmission, S is a “special” subframe used for a guard time,and U is a subframe for uplink transmission. Subframe number 0 to 9indicate the indices of subframes constituting one radio frame. Skilledin the art should appreciate that the allocations indicated in FIG. 2are intended to be exemplary and alternative sets of predeterminedallocations may also be used.

In case of TDD UL-DL configuration #3, the evolved Node B (eNB) or basestation (BS) can transmit downlink data and/or control information atsubframes #0, #5, #6, #7, #8, and #9, and can receive uplink data and/orcontrol information at subframes #2, #3, and #4. Here, # indicatesnumber or index. The subframe #1 as special subframe can be used fortransmitting downlink control information and/or downlink dataselectively and Sounding Reference Signal (SRS) or Random Access Channel(RACH) in uplink.

Because of the different UL-DL configuration between FDD-LTE andTDD-LTE, the HARQ timing corresponding to PDSCH and the HARQ timingcorresponding to PUSCH defined in LTE current specifications maybe notwork in the scenario of CA of FDD and TDD. In addition, in current LTEspecification, PUCCH can be only transmitted on the Pcell, and the PHICHcan be only transmitted on the component carrier which carriers theuplink grant.

In current LTE specification, for FDD systems and for single servingcell, the timing relationship between PDSCH and PUCCH carrying uplinkHARQ ACK/NACK corresponding to the PDSCH or PUSCH is defined that theHARQ ACK/NACK transmitted in subframe #n is associated with the PDSCHreceived in subframe #n−4.

For TDD systems and for single serving cell, the timing relationshipbetween PDSCH and PUCCH or PUSCH is more complicated than that for FDDsystems.

FIG. 3 illustrates the PDSCH HARQ timing for TDD defined in LTEspecification.

The UE receives the PDSCH transmitted by the eNB at an (n−k)^(th)subframe and transmits an uplink HARQ ACK/NACK corresponding to thereceived PDSCH at an n^(th) subframe. In other words, the HARQ ACK/NACKtransmitted in subframe #n is associated with the PDSCHs received insubframe #n−k. Here, k denotes an element of a set K, and K is definedas shown in FIG. 3.

In current LTE specification, for FDD systems and for single servingcell, the timing relationship between PUSCH and PHICH carrying downlinkHARQ ACK/NACK corresponding to the PUSCH is defined that the HARQACK/NACK transmitted in subframe #n is associated with the PUSCHreceived in subframe #n−4.

For TDD systems and for single serving cell, the timing relationshipbetween PUSCH and PHICH is more complicated than that for FDD systems.

FIG. 4 illustrates the PUSCH HARQ timing for TDD defined in LTEspecification.

The eNB receives the PUSCH transmitted by the UE at an(n−k_(PHICH))^(th) subframe and transmits a downlink HARQ ACK/NACKcorresponding to the received PUSCH at an n^(th) subframe. In otherwords, for PUSCH transmissions scheduled in subframe #n, the UE shalldetermine the corresponding PHICH resource in subframe #(n+k_(PHICH)),where k_(PHICH) is given in FIG. 4.

Typically, the scheduling information for the data to be transmitted onthe component carrier is transmitted to the UE in Downlink ControlInformation (DCI). The DCI can be defined in various formats.

PUSCH scheduling timing is defined in LTE specifications. For FDD, theUE shall upon detection a PDCCH/Enhanced-PDCCH (EPDCCH) with downlinkcontrol information (DCI) format 0/4 in subframe #n intended for the UE,adjust the corresponding PUSCH transmission in subframe #n+4 accordingto the PDCCH/EPDCCH.

FIG. 5 illustrates PUSCH scheduling timing for TDD defined in LTEspecification. For TDD, the UE shall upon detection a PDCCH/EPDCCH withDCI format 0/4 in subframe #n intended for the UE, adjust thecorresponding PUSCH transmission in subframe n+k according to thePDCCH/EPDCCH, where k is given in FIG. 5.

From above discussion, it can be seen that the timing relationship amongthe uplink and downlink physical channels such as control channel fordata scheduling, scheduled data channel, and HARQ ACK/NACK channelcorresponding to the data channel should be defined due to the differentUL-DL configurations in TDD system.

The same problem also exists in systems supporting carrier aggregationof FDD and TDD due to the different UL-DL configuration between FDD-LTEand TDD-LTE. Further, in either scenario of CA of FDD and TDD, thefollowing rules should be met, i.e., PUCCH can be only transmitted onthe Pcell, and the PHICH carrying downlink HARQ ACK/NACK correspondingto the PUSCH can be only transmitted on the component carrier whichcarriers the uplink grant.

FIGS. 6a-6b illustrate the scenarios of CA of FDD and TDD. Thesescenarios are classified according to the duplex mode of the Pcell.

FIG. 6a shows Scenario 1 where the Pcell is configured with FDDcomponent carrier (FDD-CC). In FIG. 6a , since the Pcell is configuredas FDD, for any time duration within a radio frame, there is a subframefor downlink (DL) transmission and a subframe for uplink (DL)transmission on different frequencies. FIG. 6a also shows one Scellconfigured as TDD. The example Scell is configured with TDD UL-DLConfiguration #2, where subframes #0, #3, #4, #5, #8, and #9 aredownlink subframes for DL transmission, subframes #2 and #7 are uplinksubframes for UL transmission, and subframes #1 and #6 are specialsubframes which can be used for downlink and uplink transmissions. Theskilled in the art should appreciate that more Scells are possible andthese additional Scells may be either configured as FDD or TDD withdifferent UL-DL configurations.

FIG. 6b shows Scenario 2 where the Pcell is configured with TDDcomponent carrier (TDD-CC). In FIG. 6b , the Pcell is configured withTDD UL-DL Configuration #2. FIG. 6b also shows one Scell configured asFDD, which has a DL subframe and an UL subframe for any time durationwithin the radio frame. The skilled in the art should appreciate thatmore Scells are possible and these additional Scells may be eitherconfigured as FDD or TDD with different UL-DL configurations.

Please be noted that, for cases where the Pcell and the Scell are bothFDD or both TDD with same or different UL-DL configurations, HARQ timinghas been defined in some specifications. The proposed solution in thepresent document intends to the case where the Pcell and the Scell havedifferent duplex modes (TDD/FDD). Thus, unless indicated explicitly, thePcell and the Scell in discussion have different duplex modes.

The skilled in the art could understand that, the scenarios may beclassified according to other factors such as scheduling modes. In theLTE-A systems supporting carrier aggregation, if the component carriercarrying DCI for data transmission and the component carrier carryingthe data scheduled as indicated by the DCI differ from each other, thisis referred to as cross carrier scheduling. Meanwhile, if the componentcarrier carrying the DCI for data transmission and the component carriercarrying the data scheduled as indicated by the DCI are identical witheach other, this is referred to as self scheduling. The Pcell can not becross carrier scheduled by any Scell. A Scell can be cross carrierscheduled by the Pcell or another Scell.

In the following, proposed solutions for uplink HARQ-ACK/NACK feedbacktiming and downlink HARQ-ACK/NACK feedback timing will be described withreference to the above scenarios, respectively. Generally speaking, theHARQ timing is determined according to one or more of the followingfactors: duplex modes of the Pcell and the Scell, scheduling mode of theScell, and some predefined rules. The duplex mode is selected from TDDand FDD. The scheduling mode is selected from self scheduling and crosscarrier scheduling. For uplink HARQ feedback, the predefined rules maycomprise that PUCCH carrying the uplink HARQ feedback can be onlytransmitted on a component carrier of the Pcell. For downlink HARQfeedback, the predefined rules may comprise that PHICH carrying thedownlink HARQ feedback can be only transmitted on the component carrierwhich carriers the uplink grant.

HARQ-ACK/NACK Timing for Downlink Transmission Scenario 1

For Scenario 1 where the Pcell is configured as FDD, the Pcell canfollow its own PDSCH HARQ timing, i.e., the HARQ timing predeterminedfor FDD in current LTE specification. More specifically, theHARQ-ACK/NACK transmitted in subframe #n is associated with the PDSCHreceived in subframe #n−4.

One Scell in Scenario 1 can also follow the HARQ timing of the Pcell forboth self scheduling and cross carrier scheduling. That is, theHARQ-ACK/NACK transmitted in subframe #n is associated with the PDSCHreceived in subframe #n−4.

FIG. 7 illustrates a timing relationship among physical channels for usein a case where the Pcell is configured as FDD according to an exemplaryembodiment of the present invention. In the example in FIG. 7, a Scellis configured with TDD UL-DL configuration #1.

Referring to FIG. 7, the black bold lines indicate the Pcell HARQ timingrelationship, i.e., the uplink HARQ feedback in subframe #n isassociated with the PDSCH received in subframe #n−4. In FIG. 7, the thinsolid lines indicate the Scell HARQ timing referring the HARQ timing ofthe Pcell according to one embodiment. However, the Scell configuredwith TDD UL-DL configuration #1 can receive downlink transmission onlyin subframes #0, #1, #4, #5, #6, and #9, and thus the correspondinguplink HARQ feedback is transmitted in UL subframes #4, #5, #8, #9 ofthe current radio frame i and in UL subframes #1 and #4 of the nextradio frame i+1 on the component carrier of the Pcell when the HARQfeedback is carried on PUCCH. FIG. 7 also shows the Scell HARQ timingreferring its own HARQ timing (indicated by thin dotted lines), i.e.,the HARQ timing for TDD UL-DL configuration #1, which has been discussedwith respect to FIG. 3.

From the comparison of the two kinds of HARQ timing for Scell, it can beseen that the proposed timing (indicated by thin solid lines) candecrease the HARQ feedback delay compared with the scheme that Scellfollows its own HARQ timing configuration (indicated by thin dottedlines).

Scenario 2

For Scenario 2 where the Pcell is configured as TDD, the Pcell canfollow its own PDSCH HARQ timing. i.e., the HARQ timing predeterminedfor TDD in current LTE specification as previously discussed withrespect to FIG. 3.

For a Scell (FDD-CC) in Scenario 2, the HARQ timing can be determinedfurther based on the scheduling modes of the Scell.

If the Scell is cross carrier scheduled by the Pcell or by anotherScell, the Scell can refers the HARQ timing of the Pcell (TDD-CC).

FIG. 8 illustrate a timing relationship among physical channels for usein a case where the Pcell is configured as TDD and the Scell (FDD-CC) iscross carrier scheduled, according to an exemplary embodiment of thepresent invention. In the example in FIG. 8, the Pcell is configuredwith TDD UL-DL configuration #1.

Referring to FIG. 8, the black bold lines indicate the Pcell HARQ timingrelationship, i.e., the uplink HARQ feedback timing for TDD UL-DLconfiguration #1.

In FIG. 8, the thin solid lines indicate the Scell HARQ timing referringthe HARQ timing of the Pcell according to one embodiment. However, sincethe Pcell is configured with TDD UL-DL configuration #1, only subframes#0, #1, #4, #5, #6, and #9 can be used to receive downlink transmission,and thus the subframes of the Scell (FDD-CC) which correspond to uplinksubframes of the Pcell (TDD-CC) cannot be used for downlinktransmission. For example, subframes #2, #3, #7, and #8 of the Scell areunavailable for downlink transmission, which are indicated by dashedblocks in FIG. 8. Referring the HARQ timing of the Pcell, for example,the BS transmits PDSCH to the UE through the Scell at the subframe #0.Then, according to the timing relationship defined for TDD UL-DLconfiguration #1, the UE will transmits the HARQ-ACK/NACK correspondingto the received PDSCH at the subframe #7 through the Pcell.

If the Scell is self scheduled, several solutions have been proposed forthe HARQ timing of the Scell.

Solution 1

The first solution is that the Scell refers the HARQ timing of thePcell.

FIG. 9 illustrate a first example timing relationship among physicalchannels for use in a case where the Pcell is configured as TDD and theScell (FDD-CC) is self scheduled, according to an exemplary embodimentof the present invention. In the example in FIG. 9, the Pcell isconfigured with TDD UL-DL configuration #6.

Referring to FIG. 9, the black bold lines indicate the Pcell HARQ timingrelationship, i.e., the uplink HARQ feedback timing for TDD UL-DLconfiguration #6, which has been discussed with respect to FIG. 3.

In FIG. 9, the thin solid lines indicate the Scell HARQ timing referringthe HARQ timing of the Pcell according to the first solution. However,since the Pcell is configured with TDD UL-DL configuration #6, onlysubframes #0, #1, #5, #6, and #9 can be used to receive downlinktransmission, and thus the subframes of the Scell (FDD-CC) whichcorrespond to uplink subframes of the Pcell (TDD-CC) cannot be used fordownlink transmission. For example, subframes #2, #3, #4, #7, and #8 ofthe Scell are unavailable for downlink transmission, which are indicatedby dashed blocks in FIG. 9. Referring the HARQ timing of the Pcell, forexample, the BS transmits PDSCH to the UE through the Scell at thesubframe #0. Then, according to the timing relationship defined for TDDUL-DL configuration #6, the UE will transmits the HARQ-ACK/NACKcorresponding to the received PDSCH at the subframe #7 through thePcell.

The first solution has advantage in little impact to the existingspecifications. However, since some downlink subframes of the Scell areunavailable, the peak rate will be decreased.

Solution 2

The second solution is that the Scell refers the HARQ timing of one TDDUL-DL configuration which has more available downlink subframes then theTDD UL-DL configuration of the Pcell.

FIG. 10 illustrate a second example timing relationship among physicalchannels for use in a case where the Pcell is configured as TDD and theScell (FDD-CC) is self scheduled, according to an exemplary embodimentof the present invention. In the example in FIG. 10, the Pcell isconfigured with TDD UL-DL configuration #6.

Referring to FIG. 10, the black bold lines indicate the Pcell HARQtiming relationship, i.e., the uplink HARQ feedback timing for TDD UL-DLconfiguration #6.

In FIG. 10, the thin solid lines indicate the Scell HARQ timingreferring another TDD configuration (e.g., TDD UL-DL configuration #3)according to the second solution. As shown, since TDD UL-DLconfiguration #3 have more downlink subframes than TDD configuration #6of the Pcell, more downlink subframes of the Scell can be available fortransmission. For example, the BS transmits PDSCH to the UE through theScell at the subframe #7. Then, according to the timing relationshipdefined for TDD UL-DL configuration #3, the UE will transmits theHARQ-ACK/NACK corresponding to the received PDSCH at the subframe #3 ofthe next radio frame i+1 through the Pcell. With this second solution,only 3 subframes #2, #3, #4 of the Scell are unavailable for downlinktransmission, which are indicated by dashed blocks in FIG. 10.

For comparison, FIG. 10 also shows the Scell HARQ timing referring thePcell configuration according to the first solution. In this case, 5subframes #2, #3, #4, #7, and #8 of the Scell are unavailable fordownlink transmission.

Thus, the second solution also has advantages in little impact to theexisting specifications. Moreover, the second solution can provide muchmore available downlink subframes compared with the first solution andthereby the peak rate is higher.

FIG. 11 shows a table for the number of available downlink subframesaccording to the second solution. The configuration referred by theScell may be represented as “Scell HARQ timing reference configuration”.

In the table of FIG. 11, the first line is the TDD UL-DL configurationfor Pcell, the second line is the TDD UL-DL configuration of the ScellHARQ timing reference configuration, and the third line is the number ofavailable downlink subframes for the Scell (FDD-CC). For the purpose ofcomparison, a fourth line is added to show the number of availabledownlink subframes for the Scell according to the first solution.

For example, if the Pcell is configured with TDD configuration #3, thenthe Scell (FDD) can refer the HARQ timing of TDD configuration #4 or #5.The numbers of available DL subframes for the two configurations #4 and#5 are 8 and 9, respectively, each of which is greater than the number(7) of available DL subframes when referring the Pcell configuration(i.e., TDD configuration #3).

Solution 3

The third solution is to define a new HARQ timing specific to the Scell.

The designing of the HARQ timing for the Scell (FDD) may be performed bythree steps. At Step 1, for a first DL subframe which is also DLsubframe in the Pcell (TDD), the timing of the first DL subframe isidentical with the timing for the Pcell.

At Step 2, for a second DL subframe which is UL subframe in the Pcell(TDD), the timing of the second DL subframe is identical with a maximumof a timing of a DL subframe of the Pcell which is closest to the secondDL subframe and a processing delay. That is, the timing must be notsmaller than the processing delay (e.g., 4 ms). Further, during the Step2, the feedback delay may also be taken into consideration. Apparently,the feedback delay should be kept as small as possible.

At optional Step 3, the timing is further adjusted according to thenumber of UL subframes of the Pcell, in order to balance the HARQfeedback overhead (i.e., PUCCH overhead) among the UL subframes of thePcell, meanwhile minimizing HARQ feedback delay. Thus, the transmissionsof HARQ-ACK/NACK are distributed in the uplink subframes of the Pcell asequally as possible.

FIG. 12 depicts an exemplary design process for a Scell (FDD) in a casewhere the Pcell is configured as TDD and the Scell (FDD) is selfscheduled according to the third solution of the present invention. Inthe example in FIG. 12, the Pcell is configured with TDD UL-DLconfiguration #1, and the HARQ timing relationship is shown through thesolid arrows in the figure. In each radio frame of the Pcell, there arefour UL subframes, and thus there are four sets K, which are {7, 6},{4}, {7, 6} and {4}. Each set K corresponds to an UL subframe. The set Kand its element k are defined in FIG. 3 as described previously.

When designing for the Scell (FDD) according to the third solution, atthe Step 1, for subframes #0, #1, #4, #5, #6, and #9 (a first type of DLsubframe), which are also DL subframes in the Pcell (TDD configuration#1), the timing of these DL subframe is identical with the timing forthe Pcell. Thus, four sets can be obtained, {7, 6}, {4}, {7, 6} and {4}.

At the Step 2, for subframes #2, #3, #7, and #8 (a second type of DLsubframe), which are UL subframes in the Pcell (TDD), the timing ofthese DL subframe is identical with a maximum of a timing of a DLsubframe of the Pcell which is closest to the second DL subframe and aprocessing delay (4 ms in this example). For example, the timing forsubframe #2 is identical with that for subframe #1 whose HARQ ACK/NACKwill be transmitted in subframe #7 of the radio frame i. Thus, the HARQACK/NACK corresponding to subframe #2 will also be transmitted insubframe #7 of the radio frame i, and therefore k value for subframe #2is 5. Similarly, the timing for other subframes #3, #7, and #8 can bedetermined. Then, the four sets can be updated as {7, 6, 5}, {5, 4}, {7,6, 5} and {5, 4}.

Optionally, the design may be further optimized at Step 3 to balance theHARQ feedback overhead among the UL subframes of the Pcell. The size ofeach set should be close to 10/N, where N is the number of UL subframesof the Pcell. In the example in FIG. 12, N=4. Therefore, afteradjustment at Step 3, the four sets are still {7, 6, 5}, {5, 4}, {7, 6,5} and {5, 4}.

Finally, the four sets {7, 6, 5}, {5, 4}, {7, 6, 5} and {5, 4} are usedfor the HARQ timing of the Scell.

FIG. 13 depicts another exemplary design process for a Scell (FDD) in acase where the Pcell is configured as TDD and the Scell (FDD) is selfscheduled according to the third solution of the present invention. Inthe example in FIG. 13, the Pcell is configured with TDD UL-DLconfiguration #3, and the HARQ timing relationship is shown through thesolid arrows in the figure. In each radio frame of the Pcell, there arethree UL subframes, and thus there are three sets K, which are {11, 7,6}, {6, 5} and {5, 4}, corresponding to UL subframe #2, #3, and #4,respectively.

At the Step 1, for subframes #0, #1, #5, #6, #7, #8, and #9 (a firsttype of DL subframe), the timing of these DL subframe is identical withthe timing for the Pcell. Thus, three sets can be obtained, {11, 7, 6},{6, 5} and {5, 4}.

At the Step 2, for subframes #2, #3, and #4 (a second type of DLsubframe), the timing of these DL subframe is identical with a maximumof a timing of a DL subframe of the Pcell which is closest to the secondDL subframe and a processing delay (4 ms in this example). For example,the closest DL subframe of the Pcell to subframe #2 of the Scell is DLsubframe #1, and thus the timing for subframe #2 is identical with thatfor subframe #1 whose HARQ ACK/NACK will be transmitted in subframe #2of the next radio frame i+1. Thus, the HARQ ACK/NACK corresponding tosubframe #2 will also be transmitted in subframe #2 of the next radioframe i+1, and therefore k value for subframe #2 is 10. Similarly, thetiming for other subframes #3 and #4 can be determined. Then, the threesets are updated as {11, 10, 9, 8, 7, 6}, {6, 5} and {5, 4}.

Optionally, the design is further optimized at Step 3 to balance theHARQ feedback overhead among the UL subframes of the Pcell. In thisexample, the number of UL subframes of the Pcell is N=3, and theroundness of 10/N is 3. The three sets are so adjusted that the size ofeach set is close to 3, meanwhile minimizing the feedback delay.Specifically, in the example in FIG. 13, subframe #8 is moved into thethird set, and subframes #5 and #6 are moved into the second set. Afteradjustment, the three sets are updated as {11, 10, 9, 8}, {8, 7, 6} and{6, 5, 4}.

Finally, the three sets {11, 10, 9, 8}, {8, 7, 6} and {6, 5, 4} are usedfor the HARQ timing of the Scell.

FIG. 14 illustrates the PDSCH HARQ timing for the Scell (FDD) in a casewhere the Pcell is configured as TDD and the Scell (FDD) is selfscheduled according to the third solution of the present invention.

The UE receives the PDSCH transmitted by the eNB at an (n−k)^(th)subframe and transmits an uplink HARQ ACK/NACK corresponding to thereceived PDSCH at an n^(th) subframe. In other words, the HARQ ACK/NACKtransmitted in subframe #n is associated with the PDSCHs received insubframe #n−k. Here, k denotes an element of a set K, and K is definedas shown in FIG. 14.

According to the third solution, since a new HARQ timing is defined,much more changes will be introduced into the existing specifications.However, high peak rate can be achieved, because all the FDD-CC DLsubframes of the Scell can be used. In addition, the HARQ feedback delaycan be kept low.

Above thus have discussed PDSCH HARQ timing for systems supporting CA ofFDD and TDD. For a BS, it can transmit a DL physical channel (e.g.,PDSCH) to a UE through one of the Pcell and Scell. Then, it can receivethe HARQ feedback corresponding to the DL physical channel of the Pcellat a first timing predetermined for the Pcell. The BS can receive theHARQ feedback corresponding to the DL physical channel of the Scell at asecond timing. The second timing is determined according one or more ofthe following factors: duplex modes of the Pcell and the Scell, ascheduling mode of the Scell, and predefined rules. The predefined rulesmay comprise that the HARQ feedback (e.g., carried by PUCCH) can only betransmitted on a component carrier of the Pcell.

When the Pcell is configured as FDD, the second timing is identical withthe first timing for both self scheduling and cross carrier schedulingof the Scell.

When the Pcell is configured as TDD, the second timing is identical withthe first timing for cross carrier scheduling of the Scell.

When the Pcell is configured as TDD and the Scell is configured as FDD,for self scheduling of the Scell, the second timing can be determinedaccording to any one of the following: being identical with the firsttiming; being identical with a third timing for a TDD configurationwhich has more available DL subframes than the TDD configuration of thePcell; and a fourth timing specific to the Scell.

The fourth timing can be designed according to the description of thethird solution (Solution 3) with reference to FIGS. 12-14.

For a UE, it can receive a DL physical channel (e.g., PDSCH) from a BSthrough one of the Pcell and Scell. Then, it can transmit the HARQfeedback corresponding to the DL physical channel of the Pcell at afirst timing predetermined for the Pcell. The UE can transmit the HARQfeedback corresponding to the DL physical channel of the Scell at asecond timing.

HARQ-ACK/NACK Timing for Uplink Transmission

As mentioned above, the scenarios of CA of FDD and TDD can be classifiedaccording to scheduling modes. In the LTE-A systems supporting carrieraggregation, the scheduling mode can be selected from a self schedulingand a cross carrier scheduling. The Pcell can not be cross carrierscheduled by any Scell. A Scell can be cross carrier scheduled by thePcell or another Scell. Since the PHICH which carriers downlink HARQACK/NACK feedback can be only transmitted on the component carrier whichcarriers the uplink grant (i.e., on PDCCH), in the following,description of downlink HARQ timing along with the uplink (PUSCH)scheduling will be given with respect to Scenario A (self scheduling)and Scenario B (cross carrier scheduling).

Scenario A

For Scenario A where the serving cells comprising the Pcell and at leastone Scell are self scheduled, these serving cells, either configured asFDD or TDD, can just refer their own PUSCH scheduling and HARQ timing.

FIG. 15 illustrates a timing relationship among physical channels foruse in a case where the serving cells are self scheduled, according toan exemplary embodiment of the present invention. In the example of FIG.15, the Pcell is configured with TDD configuration #2, and the Scell isconfigured as FDD.

Referring to FIG. 15, the black bold lines indicate the uplink granttiming of Pcell, i.e., the PUSCH scheduling timing for TDD UL-DLconfiguration #2, which has been discussed with reference to FIG. 5. Forexample, upon detection a PDCCH/EPDCCH with DCI format 0/4 in subframe#3 intended for a UE, the UE will adjust the corresponding PUSCHtransmission in subframe #7 in the current radio frame i; upon detectiona PDCCH/EPDCCH with DCI format 0/4 in subframe #8 intended for the UE,the UE will adjust the corresponding PUSCH transmission in subframe #2within the next radio frame i+1.

The bold dotted lines indicate the uplink grant timing of Scell. Forexample, upon detection a PDCCH/EPDCCH with DCI format 0/4 in subframe#n intended for the UE, the UE will adjust the corresponding PUSCHtransmission in subframe #n+4.

In FIG. 15, the thin solid lines indicate the HARQ timing of the Pcellwhich refers its own HARQ timing according to one embodiment. Forexample, the UE transmits PUSCH in UL subframe #7 of the current radioframe i through the Pcell, and then the UE will receive the HARQfeedback corresponding to the transmitted PUSCH in DL subframe #3 of thenext radio frame i+1 through the Pcell. If the UE transmits PUSCH in ULsubframe #2 of the radio frame i+1, the UE will receive the HARQfeedback corresponding to the transmitted PUSCH in DL subframe #8 of theradio frame i+1 through the Pcell.

The thin dotted lines indicate the HARQ timing of the Scell (FDD) whichrefers its own HARQ timing according to one embodiment. For example, theUE transmits PUSCH in UL subframe #n, and then the UE will receive theHARQ feedback corresponding to the transmitted PUSCH in DL subframe#n+4.

Scenario B

For Scenario B where the serving cell is cross carrier scheduled, thereare two cases. Case 1 is that a FDD-CC cell schedules a TDD-CC cell, andCase 2 is that a TDD-CC cell schedules a FDD-CC cell. In the following,terms “a scheduling cell” and “a scheduled cell” will be introduced. Incross carrier scheduling, a cell whose component carrier carries DCI fordata transmission is a scheduling cell, and a cell whose componentcarrier carrying the data scheduled as indicated by the DCI is ascheduled cell.

The scheduling cell (regardless Pcell or Scell) can just refer its ownscheduling and HARQ timing.

For a scheduled cell, different solutions may be adopted depending onthe case the scheduled cell belongs to.

In Case 1 where the scheduled cell is configured as TDD and scheduled bya FDD-CC cell, the scheduled cell can just refer its own scheduling andHARQ timing. Since the scheduling cell (FDD) always has DL subframes inany specific time duration, the DL subframes of the scheduling cell canbe used by the scheduled cell for HARQ ACK/NACK feedback correspondingto PUSCH transmission scheduled through the scheduling cell.

For Case 2 where the scheduled cell is configured as FDD and scheduledby a TDD-CC cell, the PDCCH/EPDCCH carrying scheduling information(e.g., uplink grant) is transmitted through the component carrier of thescheduling cell (TDD-CC), the PHICH carrying HARQ ACK/NACK correspondingto the scheduled PUSCH transmission should also be transmitted throughthe component carrier of the scheduling cell (TDD-CC). However, due toUL-DL configurations, the UL subframes of the scheduling cell cannot beused for HARQ feedback. There are two solutions to define the schedulingtiming and HARQ timing for the scheduled cell.

Solution A

Solution A is that the scheduled cell (a Scell) refers the schedulingtiming and HARQ timing of the scheduling cell (TDD-CC).

Similar to Solution 1 as discussed in section “HARQ ACK/NACK Timing forDownlink Transmission”, Solution A has advantage in little impact to theexisting specifications. However, since some uplink subframes of thescheduled cell are unavailable, the peak rate will be decreased.

Solution B

Solution B is that the scheduled cell refers the scheduling timing andHARQ timing of one TDD UL-DL configuration which can use more uplinksubframes of the scheduled cell as much as possible. Similar to Solution2 as discussed in section “HARQ ACK/NACK Timing for DownlinkTransmission”, Solution B also has advantage in little impact to theexisting specifications. Moreover, Solution B can provide much moreavailable uplink subframes compared with Solution A and thereby the peakrate is higher.

FIG. 16 shows a table for the number of available uplink subframesaccording to Solution B. The configuration referred by the scheduledcell may be represented as “reference configuration of Solution B”.

In the table of FIG. 11, the first column is the TDD UL-DL configurationfor the scheduling cell, and the second column is the TDD UL-DLconfiguration of the scheduled cell reference configuration. For thepurpose of comparison, a third column is added to show the number ofavailable uplink subframes for the scheduled cell according to SolutionA. In the second column, the value in the parenthesis is the number ofavailable UL subframes when a corresponding TDD UL-DL configuration isreferenced by the scheduled cell.

For example, if the scheduling cell is configured with TDD configuration#3, then the scheduled cell (FDD) can refer the scheduling timing andHARQ timing of TDD configuration #0 or #6. The numbers of available ULsubframes for the two configurations #0 and #0 are 6 and 5,respectively, each of which is greater than the number (3) of availableUL subframes when referring the configuration of the scheduling cell(i.e., TDD configuration #3).

If the scheduled cell (FDD-CC) refers the scheduling and HARQ timing ofTDD configuration #0, the PDCCH DCI format 0 and 4 will be transmittedfollowing the TDD configuration #0. At this time, an UL index field isneeded to schedule two uplink subframes in one downlink subframe.

Apparently, further solution can be provided for the scheduled cell. Forexample, a new scheduling timing and HARQ timing may be designed for thescheduled cell with reference to the design rules as discussed insection “HARQ ACK/NACK Timing for Downlink Transmission” with respect toSolution 3.

Above thus have discussed PUSCH scheduling timing and PUSCH HARQ timingfor systems supporting CA of FDD and TDD. For a BS, it can receive an ULphysical channel (e.g., PUSCH) from a UE through one of the Pcell andScell. Then, it can transmit the HARQ feedback corresponding to the ULphysical channel of the Pcell at a first timing predetermined for thePcell. The BS can transmit the HARQ feedback corresponding to the ULphysical channel of the Scell at a second timing. The second timing isdetermined according one or more of the following factors: duplex modesof the Pcell and the Scell, a scheduling mode of the Scell, andpredefined rules. The predefined rules may comprise that the HARQfeedback (e.g., carried by PHICH) can only be transmitted on a componentcarrier which carries an uplink grant scheduling the PUSCH.

For self scheduling, the second timing is identical with a timingpredetermined for the Scell.

For cross carrier scheduling, the second timing is further determinedaccording to the duplex modes of a scheduling cell and a scheduled cell.

When the Scell is a scheduling cell, the second timing is identical witha timing predetermined for the Scell.

When the Scell is a scheduled cell which is configured as TDD andscheduled by a FDD component carrier cell, the second timing isidentical with a timing predetermined for the Scell.

When the Scell is a scheduled cell which is configured as FDD andscheduled by a TDD component carrier cell, the second timing can bedetermined according to any one of the following: being identical with atiming of the scheduling cell; and being identical with a third timingfor a TDD configuration which can use uplink subframes of the Scell asmuch as possible.

For a UE, it can transmit an UL physical channel (e.g., PUSCH) to a BSthrough one of the Pcell and Scell. Then, it can receive the HARQfeedback corresponding to the UL physical channel of the Pcell at afirst timing predetermined for the Pcell. The UE can receive the HARQfeedback corresponding to the UL physical channel of the Scell at asecond timing. The second timing is determined according to thosesolutions as described above.

FIG. 17 illustrates a simplified block diagram of an entity 1700 that issuitable for use in practicing exemplary embodiments of the presentinvention. The entity 1700 may be an entity at the network side, forexample, a base station, or an entity at the user side, e.g., a userequipment.

As shown in FIG. 17 the entity 1700 includes a data processor (DP) 1701,a memory (MEM) 1702 coupled to the DP 1701, and a suitable RFtransmitter TX and receiver RX 1704 coupled to the DP 1701. The MEM 1702stores a program (PROG) 1703. The TX/RX 1704 is for bidirectionalwireless communications. Note that the TX/RX 1704 has at least oneantenna to facilitate communication, though in practice a BS or a UE mayhave several. The entity 1700 may be coupled via a data path to one ormore external networks or systems, such as the internet, for example.

The PROG 1703 is assumed to include program instructions that, whenexecuted by the associated DP 1701, enable the entity 1700 to operate inaccordance with the exemplary embodiments of this invention.

The embodiments of the present invention may be implemented by computersoftware executable by the DP 1701 of the entity 1700, or by hardware,or by a combination of software and hardware.

The MEM 1702 may be of any type suitable to the local technicalenvironment and may be implemented using any suitable data storagetechnology, such as semiconductor based memory devices, magnetic memorydevices and systems, optical memory devices and systems, fixed memoryand removable memory, as non-limiting examples. While only one MEM isshown in the entity 1700, there may be several physically distinctmemory units in the entity 1700. The DP 1701 may be of any type suitableto the local technical environment, and may include one or more ofgeneral purpose computers, special purpose computers, microprocessors,digital signal processors (DSPs) and processors based on multicoreprocessor architecture, as non limiting examples. The entity 1700 mayhave multiple processors, such as for example an application specificintegrated circuit chip that is slaved in time to a clock whichsynchronizes the main processor.

Exemplary embodiments of the present invention have been described abovewith reference to block diagrams and flowchart illustrations of methods,apparatuses (i.e., systems). It will be understood that each block ofthe block diagrams and flowchart illustrations, and combinations ofblocks in the block diagrams and flowchart illustrations, respectively,can be implemented by various means including computer programinstructions. These computer program instructions may be loaded onto ageneral purpose computer, special purpose computer, or otherprogrammable data processing apparatus to produce a machine, such thatthe instructions which execute on the computer or other programmabledata processing apparatus create means for implementing the functionsspecified in the flowchart block or blocks.

The foregoing computer program instructions can be, for example,sub-routines and/or functions. A computer program product in oneembodiment of the invention comprises at least one computer readablestorage medium, on which the foregoing computer program instructions arestored. The computer readable storage medium can be, for example, anoptical compact disk or an electronic memory device like a RAM (randomaccess memory) or a ROM (read only memory).

While this specification contains many specific implementation details,these should not be construed as limitations on the scope of anyimplementation or of what may be claimed, but rather as descriptions offeatures that may be specific to particular embodiments of particularimplementations. Certain features that are described in thisspecification in the context of separate embodiments can also beimplemented in combination in a single embodiment. Conversely, variousfeatures that are described in the context of a single embodiment canalso be implemented in multiple embodiments separately or in anysuitable sub-combination. Moreover, although features may be describedabove as acting in certain combinations and even initially claimed assuch, one or more features from a claimed combination can in some casesbe excised from the combination, and the claimed combination may bedirected to a sub-combination or variation of a sub-combination.

It should also be noted that the above described embodiments are givenfor describing rather than limiting the invention, and it is to beunderstood that modifications and variations may be resorted to withoutdeparting from the spirit and scope of the invention as those skilled inthe art readily understand. Such modifications and variations areconsidered to be within the scope of the invention and the appendedclaims. The protection scope of the invention is defined by theaccompanying claims. In addition, any of the reference numerals in theclaims should not be interpreted as a limitation to the claims. Use ofthe verb “comprise” and its conjugations does not exclude the presenceof elements or steps other than those stated in a claim. The indefinitearticle “a” or “an” preceding an element or step does not exclude thepresence of a plurality of such elements or steps.

1-32. (canceled)
 33. A method for receiving, at a base station, a HybridAutomatic Repeat Request (HARQ) feedback from a user equipment in acommunication system supporting Carrier Aggregation (CA) of a primarycell and at least one secondary cell, wherein the primary cell and thesecondary cell support either Frequency Divisional Duplex (FDD) or TimeDivisional Duplex (TDD), the method comprising: transmitting a downlinkphysical channel through at least one of the primary cell and thesecondary cells; receiving the HARQ feedback corresponding to thedownlink physical channel of the secondary cell at a second timing,wherein if the user equipment is not configured to monitor a controlchannel in another cell for scheduling the secondary cell, and when theprimary cell is configured as TDD and the secondary cell is configuredas FDD, the second timing is determined as below: for a first subframewhich is either a downlink subframe or a special subframe in the primarycell, the second timing of receiving the HARQ feedback corresponding tothe downlink physical channel of the first subframe in the secondarycell is identical with a first timing for TDD; and for a second subframewhich is an uplink subframe in the primary cell, the second timing ofreceiving the HARQ feedback corresponding to the downlink physicalchannel of the second subframe in the secondary cell is identical with athird timing for TDD of receiving a HARQ feedback corresponding to thedownlink physical channel of either a downlink subframe or a specialsubframe of the primary cell which is closest to the second subframe.34. The method of claim 33, wherein a number of downlink subframes inwhich the downlink physical channel of the secondary cell istransmitted, per an uplink subframe of the primary cell in which theHARQ feedback corresponding to the downlink physical channel isreceived, is equal to one of: ceil (a number of downlink subframes inwhich the downlink physical channel of the secondary cell is transmitteddivided by the number of the uplink subframes of the primary cell inwhich the HARQ feedback corresponding to the downlink physical channelis received); or floor (a number of downlink subframes in which thedownlink physical channel of the secondary cell is transmitted dividedby the number of the uplink subframes of the primary cell in which theHARQ feedback corresponding to the downlink physical channel isreceived).
 35. The method of claim 33, wherein the second timing isidentical with a timing for FDD, when the primary cell is configured asFDD.
 36. The method of claim 33, wherein the second timing is identicalwith a fourth timing for TDD, if the user equipment is configured tomonitor a control channel in another cell for scheduling the secondarycell, when the primary cell is configured as TDD.
 37. The method ofclaim 33, wherein a Physical Uplink Control Channel (PUCCH) istransmitted only on the primary cell.
 38. A method for transmitting, ata user equipment, a Hybrid Automatic Repeat Request (HARQ) feedback to abase station in a communication system supporting Carrier Aggregation(CA) of a primary cell and at least one secondary cell, wherein theprimary cell and the secondary cell support either Frequency DivisionalDuplex (FDD) or Time Divisional Duplex (TDD), the method comprising:receiving a downlink physical channel through at least one of theprimary cell and the secondary cells; transmitting the HARQ feedbackcorresponding to the downlink physical channel of the secondary cell ata second timing, wherein if the user equipment is not configured tomonitor a control channel in another cell for scheduling the secondarycell, and when the primary cell is configured as TDD and the secondarycell is configured as FDD, the second timing is determined as below: fora first subframe which is either a downlink subframe or a specialsubframe in the primary cell, the second timing of transmitting the HARQfeedback corresponding to the downlink physical channel of the firstsubframe in the secondary cell is identical with a first timing for TDD;and for a second subframe which is an uplink subframe in the primarycell, the second timing of transmitting the HARQ feedback correspondingto the downlink physical channel of the second subframe in the secondarycell is identical with a third timing for TDD of transmitting a HARQfeedback corresponding to the downlink physical channel of either adownlink subframe or a special subframe of the primary cell which isclosest to the second subframe.
 39. The method of claim 38, wherein anumber of downlink subframes in which the downlink physical channel ofthe secondary cell is received, per an uplink subframe of the primarycell in which the HARQ feedback corresponding to the downlink physicalchannel is transmitted, is equal to one of: ceil (a number of downlinksubframes in which the downlink physical channel of the secondary cellis received divided by the number of the uplink subframes of the primarycell in which the HARQ feedback corresponding to the downlink physicalchannel is transmitted); or floor (a number of downlink subframes inwhich the downlink physical channel of the secondary cell is receiveddivided by the number of the uplink subframes of the primary cell inwhich the HARQ feedback corresponding to the downlink physical channelis transmitted).
 40. The method of claim 38, wherein the second timingis identical with a timing for FDD, when the primary cell is configuredas FDD.
 41. The method of claim 38, wherein the second timing isidentical with a fourth timing for TDD, if the user equipment isconfigured to monitor a control channel in another cell for schedulingthe secondary cell, when the primary cell is configured as TDD.
 42. Themethod of claim 38, wherein a Physical Uplink Control Channel (PUCCH) istransmitted only on the primary cell.
 43. A base station apparatuscomprising at least one memory storing instructions, and at least oneprocessor configured to execute the instructions to: in a communicationsystem supporting Carrier Aggregation (CA) of a primary cell and atleast one secondary cell, wherein the primary cell and the secondarycell support either Frequency Divisional Duplex (FDD) or Time DivisionalDuplex (TDD), transmit a downlink physical channel through at least oneof the primary cell and the secondary cells; receive, from a userequipment, a Hybrid Automatic Repeat Request (HARQ) feedbackcorresponding to the downlink physical channel of the secondary cell ata second timing, wherein if the user equipment is not configured tomonitor a control channel in another cell for scheduling the secondarycell, and when the primary cell is configured as TDD and the secondarycell is configured as FDD, the second timing is determined as below: fora first subframe which is either a downlink subframe or a specialsubframe in the primary cell, the second timing of receiving the HARQfeedback corresponding to the downlink physical channel of the firstsubframe in the secondary cell is identical with a first timing for TDD;and for a second subframe which is an uplink subframe in the primarycell, the second timing of receiving the HARQ feedback corresponding tothe downlink physical channel of the second subframe in the secondarycell is identical with a third timing for TDD of receiving a HARQfeedback corresponding to the downlink physical channel of either adownlink subframe or a special subframe of the primary cell which isclosest to the second subframe.
 44. The base station apparatus of claim43, wherein a number of downlink subframes in which the downlinkphysical channel of the secondary cell is transmitted, per an uplinksubframe of the primary cell in which the HARQ feedback corresponding tothe downlink physical channel is received, is equal to one of: ceil (anumber of downlink subframes in which the downlink physical channel ofthe secondary cell is transmitted divided by the number of the uplinksubframes of the primary cell in which the HARQ feedback correspondingto the downlink physical channel is received); or floor (a number ofdownlink subframes in which the downlink physical channel of thesecondary cell is transmitted divided by the number of the uplinksubframes of the primary cell in which the HARQ feedback correspondingto the downlink physical channel is received).
 45. The base stationapparatus of claim 43, wherein the second timing is identical with atiming for FDD, when the primary cell is configured as FDD.
 46. The basestation apparatus of claim 43, wherein the second timing is identicalwith a fourth timing for TDD, if the user equipment is configured tomonitor a control channel in another cell for scheduling the secondarycell, when the primary cell is configured as TDD.
 47. The base stationapparatus of claim 43, wherein a Physical Uplink Control Channel (PUCCH)is transmitted only on the primary cell.
 48. A user equipment comprisingat least one memory storing instructions, and at least one processorconfigured to execute the instructions to: in a communication systemsupporting Carrier Aggregation (CA) of a primary cell and at least onesecondary cell, wherein the primary cell and the secondary cell supporteither Frequency Divisional Duplex (FDD) or Time Divisional Duplex(TDD), receive a downlink physical channel through at least one of theprimary cell and the secondary cells; transmit, to a base stationapparatus, a Hybrid Automatic Repeat Request (HARQ) feedbackcorresponding to the downlink physical channel of the secondary cell ata second timing, wherein if the user equipment is not configured tomonitor a control channel in another cell for scheduling the secondarycell, and when the primary cell is configured as TDD and the secondarycell is configured as FDD, the second timing is determined as below: fora first subframe which is either a downlink subframe or a specialsubframe in the primary cell, the second timing of transmitting the HARQfeedback corresponding to the downlink physical channel of the firstsubframe in the secondary cell is identical with a first timing for TDD;and for a second subframe which is an uplink subframe in the primarycell, the second timing of transmitting the HARQ feedback correspondingto the downlink physical channel of the second subframe in the secondarycell is identical with a third timing for TDD of receiving a HARQfeedback corresponding to the downlink physical channel of either adownlink subframe or a special subframe of the primary cell which isclosest to the second subframe.
 49. The user equipment of claim 48,wherein a number of downlink subframes in which the downlink physicalchannel of the secondary cell is received, per an uplink subframe of theprimary cell in which the HARQ feedback corresponding to the downlinkphysical channel is transmitted, is equal to one of: ceil(a number ofdownlink subframes in which the downlink physical channel of thesecondary cell is received divided by the number of the uplink subframesof the primary cell in which the HARQ feedback corresponding to thedownlink physical channel is transmitted); or floor(a number of downlinksubframes in which the downlink physical channel of the secondary cellis received divided by the number of the uplink subframes of the primarycell in which the HARQ feedback corresponding to the downlink physicalchannel is transmitted).
 50. The user equipment of claim 48, wherein thesecond timing is identical with a timing for FDD, when the primary cellis configured as FDD.
 51. The user equipment of claim 48, wherein thesecond timing is identical with a fourth timing for TDD, if the userequipment is configured to monitor a control channel in another cell forscheduling the secondary cell, when the primary cell is configured asTDD.
 52. The user equipment of claim 48, wherein a Physical UplinkControl Channel (PUCCH) is transmitted only on the primary cell.